A Scorecard For President Goodluck Jonathan

I read the recently published achievements of President Goodluck Jonathan. The list of achievements include creating new institutions (Nigeria Bulk Electricity Trading (NEBT) Plc), formulating new plans (machinery to establish 37 Skills Acquisition Centers) and a few “tangible” improvements (claims of improvement in power supply). There has been a backlash on popular news sites and Social Media questioning how tangible these achievements.

My first impression is that the list has far too many items, many of which are plans, policies and programmes. While I appreciate the list was published to coincide with the administration’s first 100 days in office, I don’t think the items on the list are weighty enough to be celebrated. When you are cooking soup, you don’t announce to the world that it will be the tastiest treat that has ever titillated their taste buds. Let people decide if the soup is actually worth all the noise.

A preferred approach to indicating progress or otherwise would be to select a few Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) based on a national vision and key objectives. In management parlance, this is called a Scorecard. Many multinational companies measure their performance using Total Return To Shareholders (TRS). This indicator shows if the company has added value to its shareholders through capital appreciation and dividend payments. Of course there are other KPIs tied to it but everyone watches just this one number. The lower level KPIs managed by the Leadership Team are often less than 10.

The Government would best be served if a few measurable KPIs are developed which show if a nation is developing or not. The average person doesn’t care about many of the achievements on that list. He is more concerned about food on the table. I suggest a short list of less than 15 items which tell of the current state of things and projects what they will be at the end of this administration. For example, a KPI could be school enrolments in 2011-25%, 2015-55%. This way, all eyes will focus on outcomes and not just activities and plans. These KPIs should have measurable targets against which to assess performance regularly, say quarterly.

The scorecard may contain the usual economic indicators such as GDP, External Debt, Interest and Exchange rates, Capital and Money market efficiency. KPIs could also cover infrastructure e.g kilometres of tarred roads, corruption, poverty, health, education etc.

My top KPIs would be as follows

  1. Hours a day without light
  2. Number of people who can afford Western standard healthcare with less than N5,000 a year
  3. Days without a major security incident
  4. Ability to feed a family with N1000 a week
  5. Time taken to drive from Kano to Lagos

Behind each of these KPIs will be a number of plans and programmes but if these things have not changed by 2015 then we will consider the administration a failure.

In addition, some of the more traditional measures could be included.

  1. Absolute and per Capita GDP Growth
  2. External Debt Levels
  3. Interest Rates
  4. Exchange Rates
  5. Power Generation (and % of generation that actually gets to consumers)
  6. Kilometres of Tarred Roads
  7. % of Nigerians below the poverty line

I believe adopting this transparent approach will give the Government focus especially if visually displayed at Government offices and shared with all Nigerians. If you were to measure the effectiveness of Government, what KPIs would you choose and how would you measure them?

Advertisements

13 thoughts on “A Scorecard For President Goodluck Jonathan

  1. The KPIs and the practical steps you have highlighted are wonderful and I am sure GEJ won’t mind borrowing a leaf here. I also agree that the average Nigerian is only interested in how he is immediately goals/achievment which is not wrong anyway and every politician should recognize that. however, I believe that the bulk of the contents of GEJ’s score card presently should be plans and not achievments as you have also mentioned. If he should not drum and dance for having plans instead of achievement, then you should also not strangle him for not having achievent knowing he has been there for 100 days only. Finally, I commend you for the detailed work you have done. this is better than those who only criticize whithout a clue or idea on how to make it better.

  2. Listen, I don’t want to believe that those in power do not know these things, cos if they don’t then they have ABSOLUTELY no business running an organization not to talk of a country.

    There SHOULD be absolutely no reason to write an article like this, that there is sense in you writing this article is a clear evidence of failure on the part of the government.

    I visited Ghana during the early years of President Kufuor, and all I kept hearing on the radio were things like the percentage of Useable and semi useable roads the then government had achieved, as well as other useful statistics.

    This is just a shame.

  3. I will prefer your score card b'cos it explains better,when u say i met electricity supply at tis rate and have increase it to tis,the state u meet a thing and the improvement or progress is better than celebrations that to an average man you are simply s on said:

    Vera yashi

  4. This is indeed one of the best short articles I’ve read about Nigeria and it’s Governance. Thumbs up to the author and thumbs up to Omojuwa for publishing this. Reno Omokri reads and shares, I hope he does this one

  5. This is so simply put and easy to measure! Well done.

    Alas, these people will never measure their achievements along these lines…it will easily show their incompetence.

    Sad.

  6. Whatever drives majority of our leaders?May the affliction never befall anyone of us(well,depending on what you seek life).Good to read a befittingly simplistic article on governance.

  7. I enjoyed reading this. Your indicators are a little too specific – they imply someone wants to get some work done. No, I am not disillusioned, merely tired 😉

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s